Save on Energy Costs: Install a Heat Pump or Solar Hot Water System?

With energy prices constantly in flux, New Zealand homeowners seek hot water solutions that minimise expenses while providing reliable output for bathing, cleaning, and heating needs. Two technologies leading the sustainable charge — solar and heat pump configurations — harness natural inputs to heat water using minimal electricity or gas.

We compare their functionality and cost dynamics below.

How Solar Water Systems Operate

Solar water heating uses free renewable energy from the sun to warm fluids transferring that collected heat directly or indirectly to insulated storage tanks feeding homes. Solar collectors are mounted outdoors, usually roof-mounted, to concentrate rays into copper heat absorption coils carrying water or glycol mixtures. This preheated liquid conveys thermal energy through pipes into the cold water line entering conventional gas or electric cylinders. The existing element or burner now requires less supplemental output with prewarmed water entering, saving energy.

The Pros of a Solar Hot Water System

Solar hot water advantages include:

  • Lower energy bills — solar reduces gas or electric heating elements usage during daylight hours

  • Renewable energy — backyard solar harnesses free, abundant sunshine

  • Carbon emission reductions — operating sans fossil fuels relative to gas heaters

  • Rebates possible — governments promote renewable adoption

  • Longevity — collectors last 20+ years with cylinder replacement over time

  • Adaptable retrofitting onto existing cylinders and plumbing systems

The Cons of a Solar Hot Water System

  • Daytime-reliant only — clouds and shorter winter daylight impact effectiveness

  • Supplemental heating still required from gas or electricity

  • Higher upfront purchase costs — collectors aren’t cheap

  • Roof leaks possible — installers must seal penetrations watertight

  • Looks less sleek — pipe and panel aesthetics turn off some homeowners

  • Can require roof reinforcement — load bearing needs evaluation

How Heat Pump Water Heaters Operate

Heat pump water heaters work by extracting latent warmth from ambient air and focusing this extracted heat to steadily warm clean water stores. An integrated fan pulls outside air across system coils transferring captured thermal energy into refrigerant gases that a compressor rapidly intensifies. This generated heat gets transferred through a heat exchanger into an insulated water tank ready for household use. Modern units use superior variable speed compressors, fans and smart controls for optimal efficiency and low noise.

The Pros of a Heat Pump Water Heater

Heat pump hot water benefits include:

  • Very energy efficient — heat pumps leverage ambient thermal energy using far less purchased electricity than conventional electric cylinders

  • Cost saving design — wonderfully efficient systems realize faster payback

  • Compact aesthetic — wall-mount single units for easy installation

  • Quiet functionality — modern models hardly noticeable audibly

  • Eco-friendly electric power source — uses no direct fossil fuels

  • Government incentives offered currently — subsidies promote adoption

  • Requires no supplemental heating elements — fully self-contained heating process

The Cons of a Heat Pump Water Heater

  • Higher purchase price — systems cost more than basic electric cylinders upfront

  • Venting required — external air intake and exhaust ducting must be configured properly

  • Efficiency varies seasonally — heat pump output declines in extremely cold periods

  • Smaller tank capacities — storage volumes trailing larger gas cylinders

  • DIY install limited — specialised components and knowledge necessary

  • Underperforms below 5°C — supplemental cylinder heating needed overnight during winter in colder southern regions

Key Performance and Cost Differences

When considering solar collectors versus integrated heat pump systems for upgrading home hot water functionality while saving on monthly energy costs, key variables in play include:

  • Regional weather conditions — solar generates greater savings in sunnier northern districts whereas heat pumps outperform during southern winters.

  • Available installation space — rooftops suit solar arrays better while heat pumps mount easily on walls with proper venting.

  • Upfront costs — solar runs cheaper initially but requires supplemental cylinder while heat pumps embedded tanks cost more than all-in-one systems.

  • Energy efficiency — heat pumps achieve greater electric savings overall but solar displaces gas usage.

  • Ease of use — heat pumps operate fully autonomously while solar relies more on homeowner maintenance.

Maximise Government Rebates

One attractive incentive when opting to install renewable solar collectors or eco-friendly heat pump hot water systems includes leveraging temporary government rebates aimed at accelerating consumer adoption. Both technologies help New Zealand progress clean energy commitments, so policymakers motivate households and businesses via Kauf subsidies during early market expansion phases.

Current rebates under the Warmer Kiwi Homes program facilitate 90% of the cost reimbursements for qualified heat pump water heater installations until mid-2024 when rates get reevaluated pending budget allocations. This allows buyers to acquire advanced systems at the same initial price as old-fashioned electric cylinders. Check our website for latest funding qualification details to maximize savings. The planet and your wallet will thank you!

Contact us anytime to discuss maximising eco rebates when planning your next hot water system installation. Don’t leave cost savings on the table through delayed action or lack of reward program awareness. We make the process seamless allowing you to upgrade affordably to greener solutions benefiting New Zealand.

Contact Regional Experts Today

With expertise in all current hot water system configurations, the team at Hot Water Solutions helps Kiwis determine whether upgrading to solar collectors or efficient integrated heat pump units makes best sense for their budget, lifestyle, and geographic considerations.

We take pride in installing quality products correctly sized to handle peak demand reliably for years to come. Learn more about employing sustainable systems that minimise monthly energy costs while delivering endless hot water convenience heating and refreshing homes across New Zealand.

Use our contact us page to reach us and we will be more than happy to discuss your hot water situation. Or give us a call on 0800 497658.

At Hot Water Solutions all we do is hot water.

Share this story